Welcome again to pitching fails, where we dissect awful pitches that never had a chance of leading to a positive response.
Failures tend to be funny, sure, but they can also be instructive. They can teach us a lot about what not to do when we’re trying to create successful pitches.
So, here’s our pitch of the day:
This pitch is an epic failure on just about every level. Here’s why:
Fail #1: Opening with “Hi”
Sure, it’s better than opening with “Hey f**ker.” But not by much.
I don’t see my name anywhere in the email. Which, as you may know by now, indicates a lack of effort on the part of the sender. It usually means they haven’t done their research, or it’s a templated email, making a win-win proposition dubious at best.
Of course, there’s no mention of a win-win proposition anywhere, to begin with… but we’ll get to that.
Fail #2: Zero Compliments
This came up last time as well (have you noticed how bad pitches tend to follow a pattern?).
I want to be clear that you don’t include a compliment in a pitch just because you want to butter someone up (although you might)…
A relevant compliment immediately shows the recipient that you care enough to do your homework and that you might have something of value to say.
There is no indication whatsoever that our eager sponsor did any work in this regard, and it shows.
Fail #3: “Looking for the Best Websites…”
Here our opportunity-hungry weasel sniffer shows just how self-interested he is.
At this point in the pitch (and really at any point in the pitch), he has given us zero reason to help him. So, why would we?
We don’t care that he’s looking for the best websites, whatever that means to him.
I don’t hate the implication that my website is one of the best (and it clearly is), but it is implied, not expressly stated.
Why does the fact that you’re looking for the best websites matter to me? Answer the question!
Fail #4: Topical Mismatch
It’s nice to know that his articles or links won’t have anything to do with casinos, loans, adult sites, or gambling.
But.
What does business, tech, fashion, or crypto have to do with the music business?
Well, quite a bit. But we’re giving our friend way too much credit if we think that he’s somehow going to tie his articles into our content ecosystem.
Instead of writing an article like 10 Music Industry Tech Innovations You Should Know About, he’s probably going to hand over something like 5 Summer Women Fashion Trends for Young Girls and Women (awkward wording and all).
I don’t need that, and he’s not going to benefit from it either. Somehow, he just hasn’t figured it out yet.
Fail #5: Telling the Blog Owner How to Manage Their Blog
It’s always a good day when someone pitches me and tells me how I should run or maintain my blog or website. It’s my property – I reserve the right to do what I want with it!
Did you notice what he said? He said, “Post without sponsored tags.”
It’s a bit of a grey area (well, on the blacker side of the pond), but disclosing sponsored content is generally word to the wise.
His ignorance is on full display here, because even when content is revealed to be sponsored content, it generally isn’t noticed by readers/listeners/viewers. So, it should not impact his campaign one iota.
But the worst part about this is the fact that when he sends me the badly titled 5 Summer Women Fashion Trends for Young Girls and Women article, it’s going to stick out like a sore thumb and NOT look like something we wrote and published.
He loses no matter how we cut the pie, but in his ill-attributed zeal, this eludes him completely.
Fail #6: Bad Grammar
It doesn’t really get bad until the end, but…
As the recipient of a garbled message like this, I’m thinking:
“If they can’t even be bothered to write a coherent email, what are the chances they’re going to phone in the article too?”
Nine times out of 10 I’m proven right.
Either way, these are the two eternal sins that condemn the pitch to hell:
- “If you are interested in publishing guest post articles on your websites.” Was this intended as a complete sentence? Because it sure seems like it’s a sentence fragment with a missing question.
- “Waiting for your positive re sponse.” Was someone typing a little too fast? There are too many spaces, an unneeded carriage return, and no comma.
Fail #7: Nothing in it for Me
Look, I understand that he offered to pay me. But chances are it won’t be more than $30, and he’ll probably want to negotiate even further down.
Not to mention, whatever content he provides me with is bound to be junk, benefiting no one in the equation.
By the time we’ve exchanged a dozen messages, and he finally sends me an article that I’ll personally end up having to edit, it will not have been worth the $5.50 he ”paid” me.
Folks, when pitching, you’ve got to know what your value proposition is!
When pitching, you’ve got to know what your value proposition is! Share on XWhat He Did Right
Not much! But what little he did right, we can still learn from.
- He said “Hi.” So, he’s at least acknowledging that someone might be on the other side of his communication. I think…
- He promised not to spam. He did say that his articles and links would have nothing to do with casinos, loans, adult sites, and gambling. It’s suspect, but if he’s telling the truth, the credibility scale would inch up a tiny bit.
- He sent the message. Many people never make it this far, so perhaps our guest-posting friend should be commended.
Conclusion
So, what did you learn today?
Have you been making any of the above errors?
Let me know in the comments.






0 Comments