Alternative to Bandcamp, Nimbit & Gumroad?

by | Feb 13, 2023 | Uncategorized

Are you looking for an alternative to Bandcamp, Nimbit and/or Gumroad?

Note: this page contains links to affiliate offers. If you buy through our links, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Thanks for your support.

If you’re making music, you need a way to sell it.

For most musicians, it’s a foregone conclusion that one can distribute their music through services like CD Baby and Ditto Music, and get up and running on all the popular platforms like Spotify, Apple Music, Google Play, Amazon, Deezer, and others.

And, if you didn’t know you could do that, well, that might be another blog post for another time.

Distribution, however, shouldn’t be equated with marketing, or for that matter, sales. Just because your music is out there doesn’t mean people will listen to it let alone buy it.

A sale is where a transaction takes place. It’s where a customer exchanges their money for a desired product or service, like music.

A stream is not a sale. It’s just a stream.

By the way, the condensed, video version of this post is right here:

Enter Bandcamp, Nimbit, Gumroad & Other Services

We certainly aren’t in the dark ages anymore.

When Derek Sivers started CD Baby in 1998, selling online was a serious endeavor. You needed a merchant account, which wasn’t easy to get. In Derek’s case, hand coding a software solution was part of the process, too.

25 years isn’t that long ago, but since then, plenty of eCommerce platforms, scripts, apps, widgets and plugins have been introduced, giving us the ability to release and sell our music through a variety of means.

With these tools, we didn’t always have complete control over pricing, or what the buyer saw, but it was better than not being able to sell our music at all.

These days, we’ve got some great tools like Bandcamp, Nimbit, Gumroad and others.

(Nimbit, unfortunately, ended up closing its doors in December 2020.)

These platforms offer more customization in terms of layout, design, and even pricing. They give you the ability to get your music in front of your audience and drive sales in a way that leaves you feeling empowered.

Hold the Phone – is Selling Music Even a Thing Anymore?

Conventional wisdom has it that music sales are dead. This is untrue.

Conventional wisdom has it that music sales are dead. This is untrue. Share on X

And, I’m not just talking about the occasional fluke music sale that comes from Apple Music, or the support you get from superfans on Bandcamp, either.

In 2019, I interviewed John Oszajca from Music Marketing Manifesto, and off air, after we had finished recording, he shared with me that there’s still money in selling music.

John Oszajca, Music Marketing Manifesto

These days, even musicians are jumping on the digital sales funnel trend and are guiding their audiences through lead magnets, tripwires, and upsells where music is a part of the product set.

Again, if you don’t know what a sales funnel is or how it works, it will be the topic of another blog post, though you’re certainly welcome to check out my sales funnel for an example (Note: you can’t get through the entire funnel without giving away your email address and spending some money).

So, selling music is still very much a possibility, even if it requires you getting creative with the process and methodology.

As Daniel H. Pink, author of To Sell Is Human says:

To sell well is to convince someone else to part with resources – not to deprive that person, but to leave him better off in the end.

I’ve often encouraged my students to bundle up their music products to maximize their earnings.

After all, the economics do matter.

The economics do matter. Share on X

If you wanted to make $3,000 and only had a $1 single to sell, you’d need to sell 3,000 singles to reach your goal.

But if you bundled up your entire catalog and sold it for $100, you’d only need to sell 30 units to get to your financial goal. What a difference!

Getting Back to the Topic of Tools (Like Bandcamp)…

In the episode 195 of my podcast, I introduced a new affiliate partner.

At Music Entrepreneur HQ, we don’t just promote things willy-nilly. We only recommend products and services we understand, use, and like.

The possible exception might be products we’ve had the opportunity to audit and would recommend to a specific subset of our audience but wouldn’t have any use for ourselves.

Our latest affiliate partner is Sellfy.


When I think of Sellfy, I generally group it in with the platforms already mentioned – Bandcamp, Nimbit, and Gumroad. They are all kind of similar, though there certainly are some differences.

But when it comes to economics, the tool you use to sell your music or related products also matters.

If you want to be effective:

  • You must be able to sell both digital and physical goods.
  • You must be able to bundle products together to sell them at a higher price point.
  • And, you must be able to sell subscriptions (for the ongoing delivery of a product or membership).

Further, built-in marketing tools certainly can’t hurt when it comes to getting attention for your offer.

Sellfy offers all this and more.

You May Also Enjoy…

The New Music Industry paperbackThe New Music Industry

Earlier, I mentioned that distribution shouldn’t be equated with marketing. This is because merely getting your music on virtual and physical store shelves is not going to get it sold. You must have a strong brand and be able to get your message in front of your target audience. You need a strategy. This guide touches on practically every marketing channel available to you. Click on the link to get your copy.

Here’s What You Get with Sellfy

By comparing it to apps or sites you might already be using (like Bandcamp), I believe I’ve been able to paint a picture of what Sellfy is and how you can use it.

Sellfy has been made specifically with creators like you and me in mind.

We want to be able to spend most of our time creating rather than worrying about the litany of technical details that generally plague the creative life these days, don’t we?

Your eCommerce store

I’m frankly amazed at all the hoops musicians jump through these days to try to sell their music.

Writing ad copy? Building landing pages? Developing sales funnels?


I’m not saying these things don’t have value. If you’ve got the technical skills, go ahead, do your worst.

But if it’s going to take away from you creating, publishing, and promoting your work, it’s important to recognize it’s time you’re simply not going to get back.

A tool like Sellfy can help you get up and running fast. They even have a 14-day free trial, so you can test drive the platform before you commit.

What I Like About Sellfy

In the past, one of my favorite things about Sellfy was the Sellfy Market. Best to my knowledge, this no longer exists.

The way this used to work was that every user’s products were visible on Sellfy’s online marketplace.

So, this helped you get a bit of extra exposure, and if you were lucky, additional sales.

But maintaining such a vast eCommerce site would prove challenging in terms of resources, servers, and personnel. So, I can’t fault Sellfy for taking the knife to that part of their business.

The best part of Sellfy now is just how easy it is to use. You can create a beautiful storefront in minutes and start selling right away.

We take it for granted now, but this is still kind of a big deal. It saves you a ton of time.

There are so many other great features I could mention, whether it’s the ability to connect your own domain, accept payments from PayPal and Stripe (this instantly makes you look pro), or embed individual products and even your entire store on your website.

Payment options

The analytics are incredibly helpful too, since you can see how many visits you’re getting, what your conversion rate is, where your traffic is coming from, where your buyers are located, and more.

Sellfy analytics

So, is Sellfy right for you? You won’t know unless you try. Again, they’ve got a 14-day free trial, so you’ve got everything to gain and nothing to lose.

Final Thoughts on Bandcamp, Nimbit, Gumroad, Sellfy & Other Services

While you could use Sellfy as a Bandcamp alternative, the reality is you could also add it to your existing tool stack.

I’ve often done this myself. Recognizing that most if not all music distributors don’t upload my music to sites like SoundCloud, Bandcamp, Nimbit, Gumroad, Sellfy, and others, I would often go and do this manually, simply so that I could increase my chances of getting in front of a larger audience.

This is somewhat of an advanced strategy, and generally it’s better to send all your buyers to one place, but there’s nothing wrong with giving your buyers more options, as sometimes this can help you get sales from places you wouldn’t otherwise be able to.